We are open during regular business hours. See our delivery page for updates on shipping, delivery and pick up.

PB&J Gooey Butter Cookie

$5.75 each

A cake-like textured peanut butter cookie with a crispy shell and melt-in-your-mouth center, filled with grape jam and peanut butter morsels.

Shipping calculated at checkout.

Allergy information

While only a few of our cookies contain nuts, all are made on shared equipment that may contain traces of tree nuts. Our cookies contain wheat flour and dairy, which may not be suitable for people with gluten and dairy allergies (vegan and gluten-free selections excluded).

Add to my custom dozen

More flavors

Oatmeal Chocolate Cookie -

Oats and dark chocolate form a crispy-edged cookie with a chewy center.

Strawberry Gooey Butter Cookie -

A signature strawberry gooey butter cookie featuring a delicate, golden-crisp shell and a soft, creamy fruit filling. Each bite reveals a luscious swirl of fresh strawberries and Italian buttercream, finished with a cloud of powdered sugar and a burst of tart, freeze-dried strawberries.

Butterscotch Blondie -

Caramelized brown sugar adds an additional layer of flavor and chewiness to this butterscotch-rich blondie.

Fruity Pebbles ™ Rice Krispie Treats -

Indulge in the oversized version of the nostalgic Fruity Pebbles ™ and marshmallow treat!